20 Dogs to be Removed from Mural
New business owners taking over Stirling Tropical Wines have plans to remove about 20 dog portraits, according to Murals for Mutts, Inc.
Update: New business owner Luanne Haver says in the comment section of this article that she is working with artist Anna Hamilton to have some of the paintings moved to other businesses in Dunedin. Anna asks that any owners with questions about their pet's portrait contact Muralsformutts@gmail.com.
———
Murals for Mutts, Inc., broke the news to its Facebook fans late Friday.
Some of the beloved animal portaits featured in a downtown mural may be lost.
New business owners reportedly told Murals for Mutts that renovation plans at Stirling Tropical Wines may affect about 20 portraits.
"The animals on the bottom of the wall will remain," Murals for Mutts told its Facebook followers.
Murals for Mutts, run by managing director Dawn Carney and artist Anna Hamilton, is a group that raises money for nonprofits through public artwork.
The Dogedin mural project, which is also on the outside wall at Skip's Bar & Grill, raised money for Dunedin Doggie Rescue. Pet owners paid between $50 to $100, depending on size, for each animal to be painted into the mural. The project began about three years ago.
"As we all know nothing in public art is permanent. Although we expected more time (as promised by previous owners) but this is beyond our control," Murals for Mutts said.
More than 100 pets are painted at the Stirling Tropical Wines mural.
"We are sorry to be losing any of the animal portraits and know how special they are. We are grateful that the new owner was willing to compromise enough to save some from being painted over," Murals for Mutts wrote.
A professional photographer took photos of the animals and will provide a digital copy to owners should their pet get covered. Owners may contact the group at muralsformutts@gmail.com. The group is posting photos of some of the affected animal portraints on its Facebook page.
This is a developing story. Please stay with Dunedin Patch for updates.
[Last updated Sunday, July 15, 2012 2:05 p.m.]
bert hastings
5:42 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
i guess i will not be buy anything from that store
Ellen
7:13 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
I agree. Are the new owners out of touch?? Hope they will change their minds. Not a good way to start a new business. Ellen
Lynda Mink
6:04 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
what is the reason... they will be doing damage to their business... these murals are part of dunedin
Cecilia
6:08 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
So much for me going back in there. What a great way to get started as new owners of a business... Not a wise move $$$ wise.
Good Luck to those new owners with success in "Dog-Eden"
Andrew
7:13 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
The two dogs in the picture is Petey and Auggie Poliquin. So much apart of my parents and brothers life. Dunedin is such a dog friendly town. These two wonderful animals are missed and I is great to see them enjoying Dunedin each day. Please boycott this business for no embracing the culture of Dunedin. I want to support local businesses but I will not when they don't support the locals.
Joe
7:50 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
No big deal... Its their store they can do what they feel is best for their business. I know a lot of people like the murals, but beleive it or not some people think it's tacky. I can go either way on it myself.
J Parsons
12:21 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
well this is NOT gonna be good for their business...Starting with me and about 107 people I have already asked to boycott this place.....WELCOME idiot owners
Luanne Haver
7:50 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
As the new owner being demonized and unapproached for comment I want to say that Anna and I have worked together organizing the relocation of about 10-15 dogs most of which would still stay on our or Skip's Main St wall. This wall has a total of 41 dogs. Sorry to see most are not open to hearing from us. We have been reaching out to other Main St shop owners to spread out the distribution of these beloved pets with no takers yet so agreed to again work with Anna. This response is show all have been misformed.
Katie Dolac
8:02 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
Hi Luanne! I already have a reporter working on a follow-up to this story through the weekend. He should be contacting you!
Andrew
10:05 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
Ms. Owner
What is the new plan for the wall?
How will it fit with the Downtown decor/vibe/theme?
I was simply commenting on the content of the article, which only offered the owners with a digital photo of the memories they paid for.
Bert Halle
5:29 pm on Monday, July 16, 2012
Hello Luanne, I am so sorry for this unwelcome and rude experience you have had from Dunedin and feel ashamed of Dunedin for all the negative comments directed toward you. I have lived here most of my life and feel this is a warm city with loving people. You did nothing wrong by investing your efforts and life here, unfortunately some people have an axe to grind because they are just unhappy people, so they blame others. I hope the best for you :)
Anna hamilton
8:18 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
Yes, this is not a bad thing. Please be respectful to the new owner. We have worked together on this. Some will be moved others will have professional pictures done. please contact Muralsformutts@gmail.com if you have any concern about your pets portrait. Some of the changes have to be done because of damage to the walls. I would rather make this a celebration of the dogs than a negative thing. Please remember that every donation helped a homeless animal and to raise awareness for local animal rescues.
Katie Dolac
8:22 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
Thanks, Anna! Our reporter should be contacting you and Dawn, also. (If he hasn't already.) Bear with us, I assigned this story to him late in the day Friday so we'll be working on it through the weekend!
Cecilia
7:36 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Anna, Thank you for your perspective, though it seems most of us who love the murals respectfully disagree. Removing some so walls can be damages is a natural progression of a building BUT for new owners to remove so they can repaint - too soon and poor timing choice by them - new business owners. Dunedin is a dog town. They would have been far better served to have opened their business, gained the respect of the town, which will provide a sizable chunk of their business (NO NOT) then emabarked upon their redcorating. Their business advisor gave them so no so good advice. The dogs have been a wonderful celebration and the donations have helped and now the new owners are just going to paid right over all that. It is too too soon. Good Luck to them with their new business venture, they certainly are facing some no so happy possible customers.....
J Parsons
10:23 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
NOPE...Good luck business owner...Never see us wine lovers in your store! Pay to relocate em all...You must not be a animal lover...Oooh and sooooo hostile with your words...These pets mean alot to the familes who hired Anna to put them there..RELOCATE em with all the money you are gonna bring in....NOT...
J Parsons
10:23 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
OK..which ones in what area are being tossed, located to where or portraits done....and whats the "work" that needs to be done
Dawn Catacchio
10:14 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
Thank you for posting Katie, we want to be able to reach as many of the pet owners as possible so we can preserve their pet's portrait for them, either by photo or by relocating it.
Katie Dolac
10:22 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
Certainly! I hope that you are able to reach them all.
John Dolac
10:23 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
This is why the Patch is such a great vehicle to report community news and comment on it in real time.
T Ribby
6:35 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Well, I wish these new owners luck. There won't be many dog lovers headed to spend money at their business.
Lori
6:35 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
I have a dog and two cats at the entrance...What is their fate?
Dawn Catacchio
9:27 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Lori, please email us at muralsformutts@gmail.com so we can discuss.
Luanne Haver
6:35 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
I love animals and entrust Anna to fulfill any tribute obligations to restore their likeness. Sorry to any offended that can't see relocating is better than removing.
Stacy Pickhardt
6:35 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
I would like for the new owners to keep the mural. I think, even though it's their business, they do not understand how Dunedin is full of life and love for doggies. I think it would be a shame to paint over it, I mean, who does that?
Lori
7:36 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
How do we find out which pets are being removed?????
Katie Dolac
7:51 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Lori, you can email MuralsforMutts@gmail.com if you are concerned about your pet's portrait.
I would also like to remind everyone that this is a developing story. Our reporter has reached out to the new owner and to Murals for Mutts late Friday. We should have an update soon.
Luanne Haver
7:53 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
The mural is not being PAINTED OVER. Anna is moving some of the animal paintings into our mural and Skip"s. This article needs to be retracted.
Katie Dolac
7:55 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Thanks for the clarification, Luanne. The misinformation appeared in the sub-headline, not the story, and it has been corrected.
Tricia Smith (Poliquin)
9:05 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Obviously the new owners aren't pet lovers or residents of Dunedin. We're long time residents with 2 dogs on that part of the wall. Proud of what Delightful Downtown Dunedin has become and I support the businesses....but not Stirling Tropical Wines.
bill coleman
9:05 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Wow, What happened to property rights? Maybe the new owners want a different look for their business. Don't be so fast to bury someones dreams and hard work. These are good people with apirations of being a positive force in Dunedin. They could have opened a business in another town; but choose Dunedin. That in itself indicates their respect and feelings for our city. It's not the sign or pictures out front, it's the sign and warmth inside their hearts that really matters. Lets support them and welcome our new business neighbors.
Lori Zimmerman
3:28 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
I agree 100% with you Bill. I have been in the store since the new owners have taken over and I was very impressed with what they have done with it. Their wines are delicious and made with fruits and vegetables and low sulfites. We should be supporting our new businesses not running them in the ground before we even give them a chance. Shame on you haters!!
Jasminetea
2:44 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
I totally agree with Bill. Some of these comments are downright cruel. It's hard enough to keep a business in this economy let alone take the gamble and take one over. Wishing you guys the best of luck and welcome to Dunedin.
Anna hamilton
9:33 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Technically we are painting over some of the animals. The ones that will be removed are higher up on the wall and to the far left of the building. I am going to relocated them but it will not happen over night so I felt it important to let people know ahead of time what was happening. The ones that are going to be removed will either be repainted below or at Skip's. It will take time so I ask that everyone please be patient. We will be posting pictures on our Facebook page of the animals that will be affected.
Luanne Haver
12:21 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Thank you Bill we had hoped this would be a project we could do and include the artist so no dogs would be disrespected. I'm surprised no one from the Patch spoke to me first and a collabrative piece of information could have been printed. I have had this business since June 1 and as Anna can confirm I had no intention of wrecklessly painting over a pet. This story is causing unnecessary panic. I'm willing to work with anyone.
Jeffrey Rosenfield
12:27 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Luanne,
We can understand your situation and we don't want to make it seem like we are portraying you in a bad light. I would like to talk to you directly so we can accurately portray your side of the story. I emailed you last night but have not heard a reply back. If you could respond to that email or call me directly at 727-253-7739, I would be happy to get your side of the story and represent it fairly in my follow-up article. Thank you. Jeff Rosenfield.
Shelly Maslak
3:28 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
I think it is great that Anna and the new owner can work together. It is also nice of Murals for Mutts to paint the dogs that need removed else where. I can understand that people are upset, however, it seems the owner and Anna are doing the best they can to please everyone. The most important thing is that the money that went to putting these dogs up there went to help homeless dogs. Dogs that did not have a family to put them on these walls to begin with, a family that loved them so much to have them painted. They had no one, and Mural for Mutts offered this wonderful thing to give them food, vaccines, and other needs. Please look at the big picture here. If your dog is one that needs removed, contact Mural for Mutts, they will do whatever they can to please you.
Jeffrey Rosenfield
3:32 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Well said Shelly.
Luanne Haver
3:28 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Jeff thank you.
Jeffrey Rosenfield
3:34 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
You're welcome Luanne.
Luanne Haver
5:41 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Thanks Shelly we can all find common ground and I'm 100% supportive of Murals for Mutts cause.
Anna hamilton
5:41 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Thank you Shelly!!
Luanne Haver
5:41 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Thanks Lori we want to make it really nice and we still have one of the very few doggie dining licenses found on Main St allowing pets on the patio and the only shop that sells gifts for pets.
Lynn Thorn
4:58 pm on Monday, July 16, 2012
Hi Luanne, I sell Celtic dog gifts (collars & bandanas) at my shop - Celtic Shop of Dunedin. I have bought doggie cookies at your shop in the past & my dog loves them. I was told you were going to phase out the doggie gifts. Is this not true?
J Parsons
10:36 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Cheers to you Tricia Smith...and not with a glass of wine from Sterling!~ Too bad we couldnt all afford to have our pets painted over an pay to move them and leave Sterlings walls blank...What a attention getter that would be! :) Hey...Sterling...Welcome to Dunedin...I mean Dogedin! Cecilia and T Ribby...Thanks for your thoughts...There are MANY wine shops/wineries that are MICRO types and product like Sterlings that can be located all over the US..Just as good...Shipping is free.
Andrew
10:07 am on Sunday, July 15, 2012
After it is all said and done I do think the owners and mutts for murals will do the right thing. This is a true example of media buzz and I am guilty of falling for it. I am disappointed in the Patch for reporting 1/3 of the story. In the future all of the facts should be checked before publishing a "breaking story". I am not supporting the owner, Anna will do the right thing because of the cause and the Patch should be ashamed and it's credibility is compromised.
Anna hamilton
11:37 am on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Hi Andrew, thank you for your support of Murals for Mutts, but in the defense if the Patch, they really only used what we posted on our Facebook page to make this article. On our Facebook post I did omit the fact that I would be relocating the affected animals. The post was to let people know that there was to be painting done next week and some animals would be affected. I felt it my responsibility to the legacy of the animals and the people who have supported our mission to make it public. Once we figured out which ones would be affected I could contact the owners and get them a photograph until I was able to relocated them, either in a different location on the existing mural or on another mural in Dunedin. Repainting the animals will take time but they all will find new homes. We are working with the owner to keep the number of animals minimal. The building needs to be repainted, I will be out there cutting in around all of their little heads and bodies but the fact is, it is not possible to repaint the building and keep all of them where they are. Back to the Patch article, yes it is not quite the whole story they would have got if they asked me first, but they did take what we made public on our Facebook as reference. Stay tuned to the follow up. Thanks
Lois Leslie
10:07 am on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Ms. Haver, Please reconsider! The dog murals capture the heart and soul of our town. Every dog pictured represents a pet -- a family member -- and we are so proud to be such a dog-friendly community. Why make enemies when you could be making friends?
J Parsons
5:44 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Cant you tell by this comments shes blaming everyone....she doent care...
Susan
10:13 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
J your comment doesn't make sense the mural is staying and dogs are being added to Skips wall and rearranged into the existing mural.
Dawn Gregorcic
10:07 am on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Its Dunedin and , I've lived in Dunedin for a long time now, and I am impressed with the new owners. I've brought my friends, family, and woman's club to the Stirling Wine Store recently , and will continue to do so!!!!!!!. And, As Joel Osteen would said, show the love to people, don't be haters,. They have the right to do what they want to their own store. See you soon!!!!!!!!!
J Parsons
3:50 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
You are comparing new owners to Osteen...Enough said...YUK!
bill coleman
10:07 am on Sunday, July 15, 2012
A lesson learned. In Dunedin don't mess with dogs or oranges!
J Parsons
3:49 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
YOU GO!
Mine Opine
11:02 am on Sunday, July 15, 2012
I don't have a "dog" in this race, but am amazed how many people attempt to selfishly control situations that are really none of their friggin' business. Then when these "meddlers" do not get their way, they gin-up some drama, become hostile and attempt to inflict harm by boycotting a wonderful local business. WTF?
This psychotic need to "control, get my way at any cost or destroy them" is a behaviorial disorder commonly found in left-wing liberal democrats. (I had to add that last part :-) I have a great idea . . .Why don't some of these " outraged meddlers" use their "super-power of influence" for good instead of evil by trying to recruit some downtown businesses to share the wealth and culture of these portraits? That's just my opinion, I could be wrong . . .
J Parsons
3:49 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Maybe the new owner can just pay us all to have our pets located to another wall since she is removing us...Mine Opine...Watch your language
Larry Butard
11:09 am on Sunday, July 15, 2012
I am willing to bet that the supportive comments were solicited by the new owner. Anyone who knows Dunedin knows how the oranges and the dogs have unified our town. My dog is not on that mural but I assure you I can find somewhere else to buy wine.
Jasminetea
3:27 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
You have to be kidding. Never met them and haven't been in there shop. But as a business owner in Dunedin, will support them in their decision about their business. This is a free country.
J Parsons
3:47 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Larry, I have a list for you!
Larry Butard
11:09 am on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Dear Mine Opine,
Whatever. You don't "get" Dubedin and if you think this won't affect business, you are a fool. Leave the dogs alone.
J Parsons
3:48 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Yes...Buy Larry a bottle of wine....NOT from Sterling
Mine Opine
2:44 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Thanks for the kind words Larry . . .and your open-mindedness. You sound like a real "peach." :)
luanne haver
2:44 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
I'm sorry this misleading article has created such a storm. I am going to let Anna the artist do all the work we need. The town trusted her before and I only wish they would again. The negativity that's being written is not doing the public art movement any favors. I have agreed to keep these murals and still reading so much hatred. I will be meeting with a Patch reporter tomorrow. Maybe if everyone gets the full plan from him we can put this controversy to rest.
Mine Opine
2:44 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
By the way Larry, as a long-time Dunedin resident, property owner, community volunteer and donor I'm pretty sure I do "get it." Dunedin is wonderful little community that has worked hard gaining a national, if not worldwide reputation for "tolerance" and "freedom." However, there seems to be a handful of "intolerant" thugs making financial threats against one of our local businesses who want to exercise their own "freedom" by updating their business decor.. Sounds kind of crazy, doesn't it . . .
Jasminetea
3:27 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Touche!
J Parsons
5:44 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Anna-How much to move our pets..Dont want to be associated with Sterling
Mine Opine
2:59 pm on Monday, July 16, 2012
J Parsons,
The business owner has agreed to keep the murals, yet you continue to re-ignite the torch on this witch-hunt. Why the hostility and intolerance for a local business exercising their freedom? Please stop attempting to utilize "bully tactics" to impose your opinion on this matter.
Do you own a home? Do you own a Car? How about a business? I have a feeling that your affection for this artwork would rapidly diminish if you were faced with the sole responsibility of displaying them on your property.
Dawn Catacchio
2:17 pm on Wednesday, July 18, 2012
Please email us at muralsformutts@gmail.com so we can discuss.
Mathew Eberius, CPRP
7:48 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
Wow, 62 comments... all because a business owner wants to make improvements to their new business. This is America, no? I'm surprised the Commission hasn't tried to enact some ordinance about this already.
Jasminetea
2:13 pm on Monday, July 16, 2012
Unbelievable isn't it! This might actually scare other people away from opening businesses in the area. This is all sounding like a lynching. What a shame.
Jasminetea
2:13 pm on Monday, July 16, 2012
It would be very interesting to find out how many of the "nasties" actually patronized Sterling Winery! I'm just sayin'.
Albert P.
2:13 pm on Monday, July 16, 2012
Not a good way to endear themselves (shop) to the people of Dunedin! It is also our right to disagree and not support a business.
Anna hamilton
3:09 pm on Monday, July 16, 2012
Hello everyone, there will be a follow up story with the complete details coming tonight or tomorrow. Please don't judge the new business until you read it. I am working with the new owner on this, trust me to continue the work I have been doing. I have and always will have the best interest of the animals in mind when doing the changes. The actual changes really are more minimal than people are envisioning. Thank you. Please contact me at muralsformutts@gmail.com if you have any specific questions.
Luanne Haver
9:41 pm on Monday, July 16, 2012
I have met with Anna and invited the Dunedin Patch to our store today so please expect a thorough follow up story that explains the entire plan. It was never my intention to paint over dogs, Anna has some wonderful ideas and I trust her, I hope everyone else does too.
Katie Dolac
9:48 pm on Monday, July 16, 2012
Thanks, everyone, for your comments, concerns and questions! We just published a follow-up to this breaking news story. It may help answer many of your questions. Here's a link to the update: http://patch.com/A-wfWN
robin
5:34 am on Tuesday, July 17, 2012
as I have seen in alot of posts your going to linch the new owners in one post of the patch. quit dogging (no pun intended) the new owners they are working with the artist to move each and everyone of the animals. they will all be there, just give it time. Welcome new owners to dunedin !!!!
Luanne Haver
7:26 pm on Tuesday, July 17, 2012
Lynn, sorry I missed your question to me about the pet items, if you are interested in expanding your pet section that would be wonderful! The Health Department will not allow us to have animals in our store due to the wine. I will send you any and all customers asking for such items, glad to keep this resource available to the locals! Thanks for posting! I will come down and say hello - we have been customers to your shop in the past, I'm Scottish/Irish and your shop sings to me! Glad to know you!
Luanne Haver
7:26 pm on Tuesday, July 17, 2012
Thanks Robin!
Brynn L
4:34 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012
Update???
Mitzi Pfeffer
11:20 pm on Sunday, September 9, 2012
And for the profit of their busines, I guess these new owners would also remove paintings in St Peters Cathedral in Rome too.. Those paintings(dogs and cats) were done to memorailize beloved family members. Not to be removed. Hopefully a lack of green dollars will speak. There are many pet freindly businesses in Dunedin. Mitzi Nabu