Love this place, the Wise Guy pie is the BEST! Great wings also!
Bayshore Pizza
727-412-8677 (TOSS)
The winner of Dunedin's best specialty pie at the Dunedin House of Beers Best Pizza in Dunedin Contest 2010, Bayshore Pizza opened its doors in January 2010 and hit the ground running with owner/manager, Erik Johanson at the helm. Bayshore Pizza also offers free Wifi, daily specials, flat screen TVs, beer and wine.
- Hours: Tue - Thu, 11am - 9pm; Friday, 11am - 10pm; Saturday, noon - 10pm; Sunday, 3pm - 9pm
- Handicap Accessible: Ramp in front of Scot Shop next door.
- Founding Date: January 2010
- Payments accepted: Cash, Debit Card, MasterCard, Visa
- Food & dining options: Vegetarian
- General services: Catering, Delivery, Eat-in, Phone orders, Take-out
- Menu link: www.bayshorepizza.net/Menu.html
- ATM: Yes
- Parking: Free lot
- Private events: Yes
- Cuisine: Pizza
- Signature dishes: Wise Guy Pie - Fresh shredded mozzarella, parmesan cheeses, slices of red tomato, fresh basil & garlic.
- Price level: $
- Reservations: Accepted
- Executive chef: Erik Johanson
- Number of tables: 729
- Features: Dinner, Lunch, Private Parties
- Atmosphere: Fun
- Dress code: Casual
Rate This Business
Reviews (4)
Awesome Pizza, yummy wings, and don't forget to try the zepolis and garlic knots!!! Throw in Erik and his friendly staff and you have my family's favorite pizza place in Dunedin!!!
I've eaten their delicious pizza and recently tried the garlic parmesan wings at the Dunedin House of Beer wing contest. These were my favorite! Great local place to get quality food and friendly service.

Just had my worst experience ever at a restaurant. Myself and my family (wife and 3 kids), walk in the door and immediately (who I can only assume is the owner), immediately tells us to leave. Instantly, I am shocked. He claims that he has 10 people coming in and that he has no room or time for us. I look around and see seating for approximately 30+ patrons and only one booth is dining. At this po
int, I am thoroughly confused. He again says to come back another time and that he'll "make it up".
Sir, I am sorry, but there is no "making it up" after you humiliate myself and my family, making my children very upset and quite confused as to why we were told to leave.
I am just amazed how a small business today can actually tell paying customers to leave. Sadly, bad news travels fast and this experience will last a lifetime. NEVER will I endorse your restaurant and forever will I NOT recommend your business.
Have a nice day.